Google Maps admits its business listings are riddled with errors and outright fraudulent entries.
The news reports hit fast and furious this week when the media got wind of the millions upon millions of “faux” business listings on Google Maps, thanks to a new Wall Street Journal exposé.
It’s true that there are a ton of map listings displayed by Google on search engine results pages, but the latest estimates are that there are more than 11 million falsely listed businesses that pop up on Google searches on any given business day.
That number may seem eyebrow-raising, but it’s hardly “new news.” Recall the reports that date as far back as a half-decade — to wit:
- In 2014, cyber-security expert Bryan Seely showed how easy it was to use the Internet’s open architecture to record telephone conversations and create fraudulent Google Maps listings and locations.
- In 2017, Google released a report titled Pinning Down Abuse on Google Maps, wherein it was estimated that one in ten fake listings belonged to actual real-live businesses such as restaurants and motels, but that nefarious third-parties had claimed ownership of them. Why do this? So that the unscrupulous bad-actors could deceive the targeted businesses into paying search referral fees.
Google is owning up to its continuing challenges, this week issuing a statement as follows:
“We understand the concerns of those people and businesses impacted by local business scammers, and back in 2017 we announced the progress we’d made. There was still work to be done then, and there’s still work to be done now. We have an entire team dedicated to addressing these issues and taking constant action to remove profiles that violate our policies.”
But is “constant action” enough? Certain business trades are so riddled with fake listings, it’s probably best to steer clear of them altogether. Electricians, plumbers and other contractors are particularly sketchy categories, where roughly 40% of Google Maps listings are estimated to be fraudulent entries.
The Wall Street Journal‘s recent exposé, published on June 24th, reported on a search its researchers conducted for plumbers in New York City. Of the top 20 Google search results returned, only two actually exist where they’re reported to be located and accept customers at the addresses listed. That’s pretty awful performance even if you’re grading on a curve.
A measure of progress has been made; Google reports that in 2018 it removed some 3 million fake business listings. But that still leaves another 11 million of them out there, silently mocking …
One thought on “Roads to … nowhere?”
Sometimes the listed business is in fact where Google says it is, but in a city like San Francisco, Google might lead you up a hillside and down the other as the “shortest route”, when anyone with a modicum of understanding of our topography would simply walk around the base of the hill!
Fortunately, in my travel experience, motels and restaurants tend to exist and be where Google indicates!