For the past (nearly) 20 years, the biggest thing that’s kept the Internet free for users is advertising – banner display advertising in particular.
Bloggers and other online publishers large and small rely on revenue from web banner ads to fund their activities. That’s because the vast majority of them don’t have pay walls … nor do they sell much in the way of products and services.
Because of this, the temptation is for publishers to serve up as many display ads as possible on each page.
It’s not unusual to see web pages that tile ten or more ads in the right-hand column. Usually the content of these ads has no relevance to readers, and the overall appearance isn’t conducive at all to reader engagement, either.
And that’s the problem.
Because of conditioning, people don’t even “see” these ads anymore. The advertising space has become one big blur – as easy to gloss over as if the ads weren’t even there to begin with. (When’s the last time you clicked on a banner ad?)
Attempts to come up with other display advertising types – pop-ups and pop-unders, animations and other rich media, skycrapers and so forth – haven’t done much to change the picture. Indeed, they’re so ubiquitous – and so predictable – we don’t even consider the ads to be annoying anymore; they’re just part of the “décor.”
I’ve blogged before about how clickthrough rates on banner advertising are bouncing along in the basement, making them less and less valuable for advertisers to consider placing. And ads that are priced on a pay-per-click basis can’t be giving advertisers much in the way of revenue either, since relevance and engagement rates are so abysmally low.
The bottom line is that we now have a “lose-lose-lose” situation in online advertising:
- Advertisers lose because of near-zero user engagement, thereby limiting their potential to drive business.
- Publishers lose because ad revenues aren’t sufficient to bankroll their activities.
- Readers lose because of lack of relevance and an incredible degree of page clutter.
So it seems that the ad-supported online publishing model is in a bit of a fix – and the question is how things can evolve to create a more satisfying result for all parties.
I’d be interested in hearing your thoughts on this issue: What will online publishing look like in another five or ten years? Anyone willing to hazard a guess?